When to Avoid Filing an Insurance Claim

Say you’ve been paying home insurance since you moved in 5 years ago. The average homeowner’s insurance is anywhere between $500-$2000 per year. Maybe you pay $500 a year. As an example, say a big windstorm causes part of your fence to blow down, which will cost $950 to fix. Your deductible is $500 for a claim, which leaves the insurance company to pay $450. The claim is not worth much more than the deductible, and in this case it’s worth more to pay for the damages out of pocket. This is because the average homeowner’s policy can increase as much as 33% or more after a claim has been made. This means, your policy would increase $165 a year, which will end up costing you more than the claim would have within a three-year-span. Also, if you own more than one property, having one claim or more on your record could make you subject to a surcharge on all of your policies.

If you had to file another claim, it may increase your insurance further, or cause you to be non-renewed. Always consider the amount of your deductible versus the total the claim will cost before you decide whether to file a claim.

Remember, your claims report plays a big role in the cost of your homeowner’s premium. It’s important to always call your insurance agency and ask questions before filing the claim.

Insurance professionals will never discourage a client from filling a claim. We just want to make sure you are properly advised.

 By: KayLynn

Search Blogs

Generic filters
Filter by Categories
Filter by content type

Be Confidently Insured.

-CONTACT US SIMPLE
What type of personal insurance are you looking for? *

The Ultimate Spring Cleaning: Why March is the Month to Audit Your Life Insurance Beneficiaries

March 4, 2026

March Potholes: Is Your Collision Coverage Ready for the “Crater Season”?

March 3, 2026

Spring Skies and Structural Eyes: Why a March Roof Check is Your Best Insurance Policy

March 2, 2026

Let the Good Times Roll—Safely: Mardi Gras Liability for Your Business

February 26, 2026

The Business “Prenup”: Why Business Partners Need Life Insurance in February

February 25, 2026

Heading South? Insuring Your Mid-Winter Break Road Trip in February

February 24, 2026

Spring Dreams, Winter Schemes: Updating Your Insurance Before Your Spring Renovation

February 23, 2026

Shadow or Spring? The Quirky Science and Folklore of Groundhog Day 2026

February 20, 2026

Stocked for Love: Protecting High-Value Valentine’s Inventory with Business Insurance

February 19, 2026

New Life, New Responsibility: Why a February Arrival Means Updating Your Policy

February 18, 2026

Leave a Comment